Dansk Revisited

In my blog of 12 April 2016 A Danish Chest? Evidence from the Essex Wills, I discussed the likely meaning of the epithet Dansk,  applied to chests in early modern wills and inventories. The material below, taken from correspondence donated to the OED project by the editor of the Essex Wills, F. G. Emmison, shows the latter conducting enquiries into the likely meaning of the word back in 1975.

 

The letters.

1. 

The British Library
29th April 1975

Dear Mr. Emmison,

Dr. Wallis has passed your letter of 21st April 1975 to me for attention.

Although it might be helpful to see it in context, I have no doubt that at the time the letter was written “in Danske” refers to Denmark. I base this on the following:—

(i) In Hamlet, Act II, Scene 1 Polonius says to Reynaldo, “Inquire me first what Danskers are in Paris.” The edition of the play by H. H. Furness refers to Danske meaning Denmark; this usage also occurs often in William Warner Albion’s England (complete edition, 1612).

(ii) The Oxford English Dictionary gives several examples circa 1600 in which Dansk stands for Danish, including the one in Hamlet. Hence a Dansker means a Dane.

I am afraid there has not been time to look into the historical forms of the place-name, but it seems probable that as it was a Hansa town the German form would have been preferred. There is not much mid-sixteenth century cartography that is really useful. Ortelius Theatrum (1570) gives greater prominence to the Polish form and adds the German below it: Gedanum / Dantzick. Mercator (1595) gives the German only.

Yours sincerely,

E. J. Huddy

2.

Victoria and Albert Museum
1 May 1975

Dear Mr. Emmison,

I am delighted to know that you are pressing on with the publication of the Elizabethan Wills. I have long been an ardent admirer of your work and look forward to the publication of your Volume 3. I am afraid I can say nothing at all helpful about the term ‘ship chest’, but I do know something about ‘Danske chests’ which came, not from Denmark, but from Danzig (Gdansk in Polish). I wrote a little article about the latter, of which I am able to send you a copy. I am only too aware that it is inconclusive but I believe it sums up our knowledge as it stands at present. I am wondering whether the ship chests might be a verison of the cypress chests, some of which were embellished with galleons in full sail of with Venetian galleys. The patterns used for their decoration were somewhat standard and it may be that a version decorated with ships was favoured in this country. I do not know and maybe this is an over-fanciful guess.

Might I beg you to return the offprint when you have finished with it as I seem to have no other copy.

Yours sincerely,

Peter Thornton
Keeper
Department of Furniture

3.

5 May 1975

Dear Mr Huddy,

I am most grateful for your letter [ref] of 29 April.

Strangely enough, by the same post, I put a query to the Dept. of Furniture, V & A Museum, as to the meaning of a “ship chest”, which occurs frequently in Elizabethan wills but is not defined in O.E.D. I enclose the kind answer, which puts me in a quandary about the port from which my letter was written—“From Dansk”. Oh dear, Mr Huddy, what shall I do?! If, at your leisure (because the book does not go to the printer for another month) you can find this spelling in any English edition of a European atlas of late 16th century I should be most obliged for a further note. I enclose a xerox of the V & A letter.

Yours sincerely

F. G. Emmison

4.

5 May 1975

Dear Mr Thornton

It is extremely good of you to have written with such helpful information in your letter of 1 May. Thank you also for your encouraging remarks: Vo. 3 will be published about April 1976.

Strangely enough, by the same post, I asked Dr Helen Wallis, Supt. of the British Museuk Map Room and an old friend, about the identification of the port from which a letter was written back to England from an Essex sailor who was sick there. It ends “From Danske”. The reply, though a little guarded, plumped for Denmark, not Dansk, relying chiefly on O.E.D., which I own and had used, but ‘Dansk’ in the Dict. merely refers to the adjective, which is much better known.

I am most grateful for the temporary loan of your only remaining offprint, which I will return shortly after reading what looks like a stimulating article.

Yours sincerely

F. G. Emmison

5.

The British Library
13th May 1975

Dear Mr. Emmison,

Thank you for your letter of 5th May 1975.

I am very interested indeed to read Mr. Thornton's remarks about “Danske chests”, and I must confess it shakes my earlier conviction about the explanation of the place name in your original enquiry. Unfortunately Mr. Thornton's article is not available here at present. Clearly more information is required about the Elizabeth [sic] customs in respect of Baltic place names, but the problem seems less likely to be solved in the printed maps available here. The atlases and maps printed about 1565 were European and these appear to have used the German form “Dantzick” or the Latin “Gedanum”. The only English edition of Ortelius’s Theatrum was published in 1606.

So I should suggest that other examples must be found, possibly in the state papers and in the records of trade with the Baltic countries. I will certainly let you know if anything useful turns up.

Yours sincerely,

E. J. Huddy

6.

The British Library
16th May 1975

Dear Mr. Emmison,

I asked a colleague in the Reading Room to look into your enquiry about Dansk, and the result has further weakened the case for explaining the name as Denmark. It seems that literary critics are not all in agreement either.

The references in Hakluyt are significant in the present context, I think. I am enclosing several extracts. Danske in these examples tends to confirm Mr. Thornton's thesis, but those Elizabethan merchants trading in the Baltic perhaps used the Polish or German forms according to personal preference.

The sixteenth century printed maps used the German form, but I have found an interesting hybrid, DANTZK, on Blaeu's maps of Poland and Prussia in the Theatre du monde (Amsterdam, 1635).

As for Polonius, he did get a bit confused sometimes; and the comment on Danskers, “Right or wrong, the result is very pleasing to British ears…” puts the case for poetic licence nicely.

Yours sincerely,

E. J. Huddy

7.

1 June1975

Dear Mr Huddy,

Danske

I very much appreciate your kindness in giving me further information in your letter of 13 May.

The problem remains, so I must be cautious in the identification.

Yours sincerely

F. G. Emmison


8.

The British Library

5 June 1975

Dear Mr Emmison,

Thank you for your letter of 1 June in reply to mine of 13 May. I am wondering whether you received my letter of 16 May also, with the enclosures. I should be very interested to know your opinion regarding the references in Hakluyt as these probably represent contemporary usage. I doubt whether the argument in “Notes and queries” covers sufficient evidence; and it would follow that the O.E.D.'s definition is not adequate.

Yours sincerely,

E. J. Huddy

The photocopies 

[the headings to nos. 5 and 6 were accidentally exchanged]

1. Richard Hakluyt The Voyages, Vol. II (ed. MacLehose, Glasgow 1903)

p. 396

A letter of Thomas Alcocke to the worshipfull Richard Gray, and Henrie Lane Agents in Moscouia from Tirwill in Polonia, written in Tirwill the 26. of Aprill 1558.
My duety premised unto your worships, with commendations &c. It may please you to be advertised, yt my last I sent from Smolensco, which I trust you haue receiued wt other letters to diuers of our English men, wherein I certified you of my long retayning there, as also of my departure from thence, and howe that I had hired a Totar to bring mee to Danske. We came to a certaine village on Satterday the sixe and twentieth of Februarie, and there remained that night and Sunday to refresh our horses, intending to haue gone away on Munday earely.

2. Richard Hakluyt The Voyages, Index (ed. MacLehose, Glasgow 1905)

p. 204/2

Danske, cable market at (1557) II. 382; Leonard Brian at, 387; wax market at, 389; Thomas Alcock at 396–399; and the Narva navigation, 485
Dantiske, Robert Elson at (1555) II. 296.

p. 205/1

Danzig, II. 8; Wolstan’s voyage to, I. 15; or Gdanum, II. 10; English merchants and goods seized in, 15–18; mercantile differences settled in, 22; ships of, despoiled by Hanse merchants, 70; Sir Jerome Horsey at (1584), III. 345; burgomaster of, and William Harborne (1588) VI. 58; customs in, 59; hulk with Spanish goods, captured by the English (1589) VI. 510.

3. Louis Zettersten, ‘Danskers in “Hamlet”.’ in Notes and Queries 6 February, 1926

p. 99/1

[States that according to Dr. Gosta Langenfelt, Shakespeare's "dansker" is the medieval name of Danzig; Shakespeare meant Danes but got hold of the wrong word.]

4. G. A. Gibbs,  ‘Danskers in “Hamlet”.’ in Notes and Queries 27 February, 1926

p. 157/2–158/2

[Aims to rebut the preceding. Points to Jamieson, Scottish Dictionary: Danskeine. Danskene, s. Denmark.]

5. Nares, Glossary of words…in Shakespeare (1905)

pp. 224/2–225/1

DANSKE, Denmark; and DANSKERS, Danes.

By chance one Curan, son unto
A prince in Danske, did see 

The maid, with whom he fell in love, 

As much as man might be.

Reliques of Anc. Engl. Poetry, 240.


Them at the last on Dansk their lingring fortunes drave,
Where Holst unto their troops sufficient harbour gave.

 
Drayt. Polyolb., xi, p. 864.



Enquire me first what Danskers are in Paris, 

And how, and who, what means, and where they keep, 

What company, at what expence.

Haml., ii, 1.

The author of the Glossary to Lyndsay considers this as an erroneous interpretation, and says that it means Dantzickers; but, if he had looked at the context, he would have seen that Polonius's speech would have been nonsense with that interpretation; for how were they to find out Hamlet by inquiring for Dantzickers? Also Danish:

It is the king of Denmark doth your prince his daughter crave,
And note, it is no little thing with us allie to have;

By league or leigure, Danske can fence or front you,
friend or foe.

Alb. Engl., iii, 16, p. 70.

So that he makes a noise when he’s on horseback,

Like a Danske drummer. O, ’tis excellent.

White Devil, O. Pl, vi, 264.

In that work, indeed, it is printed Dantzic, by mistake, or by way of correction to the text; but the true reading is Danske, as indeed the metre shows it should be.

6. Jamieson Etymological Dictionary of the Scottish Language, Vol. 2 (1880)

p. 14/2

DANSKEINE, DANSKENE, s. Denmark.

“At this feild the erle of Bothuell fled away with all hes company, and passed out of Scotland to Danskeine, where he deceissit miserablie.” Marioreybanks’ Annals, p. 19.

Formed, perhaps, without sufficient reason, by mariners, from the name which an inhabitant of that country takes to himself, Danske.

It is used, however, by Skene.

“The merchandis vsis to pay fraucht for their guds to Flanders be the sek [sack], to France, Spayne, and England be the tun: and to Danskene, and the Easter Seas, be the serplath.” De Verb. Sign. vo. Serplaith.

Archdeacon Nares has satisfactorily proved that Mr. Chalmers, in the Gl. to Lyndsay, has given “an erroneous interpretation” of the term Danskers, as used by Shakspeare, as if it meant Dantzickers; adding; “If he had looked at the context, he would have seen that Polonius’s speech would have been nonsense with that interpretation, for how were they to find out Hamlet by inquiring for Dantzicker’s?” After all, Mr. Chalmers, who is never at a loss to prove what he has once imagined, may be able to shew that Danskeine, mentioned above as the place to which Bothwell fled, was no other than Dantzic.

7. Dictionary of the Older Scottish Tongue, Volume 2.

p. 11/1–2

[Two entries are relevant: a small entry, ‘Dansk, n….= DANSKIN a.’, with one 1681 quotation, and a much larger one, ‘Danskin, -ene, a. and n…. f. Polish Gdansk Danzig, with adjectival ending…1. adj. Connected with, made in, bought from Dantzig.’ There follows a list of the nouns with which it is used, including kist, and quotations from 1492 onwards. Examples with kist: ‘Ane Danskin kist with ane sey kist; 1596 Fraser P. 228; Ane Danskyne kist in the nether chamber; 1630 Bamff Chart. 223; My meikill trunk or schyryn kist, being ane Danskein kist; 1627 Edinb. Test. LIV. 106’. ‘2. n. The town of Dantzig’, with examples from the 15th to the early 17th century.

Old Implements and Instruments from the Essex Wills

Continuing my posts on the vocabulary of the Essex Wills and its place in English lexical history, an introduction to which can be found here.

The Essex Wills are naturally full of words for household goods. The majority are words that are still used, though the things to which they are applied may now be different in design or appearance. A large majority are words, or meanings of words, that are no longer used, but are carefully recorded in dictionaries, and especially in the Oxford English Dictionary. But a significant number have escaped notice by lexicographers and yet can be found, often in large numbers, in wills, inventories, and other non-literary documents of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries (and sometimes in earlier and later documents). 

This article deals with a miscellaneous collection of words for implements and instruments which seem to have escaped notice by the main dictionaries, though some occur in provincial glossaries. As usual, the Essex Wills are the entry point, but the words are found in many other documents too, most of them non-literary.

bout hammer

From the Essex Wills:

1568 (VIII. 215) 2 ‘boute’ harness [probably an error for hammers], 1 upright hammer, 1 hard hammer

1591 (VI. 4) bowt hammer

1593 (VI. 211) 1 ‘bowte’, 1 hammer.., 1 upright hammer

1598 (XII. 69) a beckhorn, 2 boute hammers, an ouperitte [i.e. upright] hammer.

This word is known from provincial glossaries to mean a blacksmith’s heavy two-handed hammer.  Later examples are fairly plentiful, and mostly localized in eastern England. Notice that unlike many of these words, it has surfaced in ‘literature’ in the form of John Bunyan.

a1630 Faithful Friends iv. v, If my wife scold, my bout-hammer shall roar.

1648 S. Marshall Sinne of Hardnesse of Heart [Wing M783] 37 Would’st thou have the stone in thy heart broken? bring it under the  bout-hammer of Gods Word. (Stephen Marshall, B.D., was a ‘minister of Gods Word at Finchingfield in Essex’.)

a1688 Bunyan Of Antichrist & his Ruin (1692) God will..break him in pieces with his bout-hammers.

1674 in D. Yaxley Researcher’s Glossary (2003) 19  2 bont hammers 1 hand hammer [probably a transcription error for bout]

1741 Dramatick Epil. in J. Holmes Grammarian’s Geog. & Astron. (1751) 257 Vulcan was drest like a Blacksmith with a Leather Apron on, and a Bout-Hammer on his Shoulder. (This text was written for Holt School, Norfolk.)

1808 Sporting Mag. Aug. 285/2 Strong as the bout-hammer.

1830 R. Forby Vocab. East Anglia I. 37 Bout-hammer, the heavy two-handed hammer used by blacksmiths. This word is not in the Dictt. however common here and perhaps elsewhere.

1846 J. O. Halliwell-Phillipps Dict. Archaic & Provincial Words I. 201/2 Bout-hammer, the heavy two-handed hammer used by blacksmiths. East. See Aboutsledge, and Beaumont and Fletcher, iv. 289.

1852 Gentleman’s Mag. Apr. 421/2 Working the bout-hammer, at the blacksmith’s anvil.

1863 W. Gee N.E.D. Vocab. Wds. beginning with Letter B, Bout-hammer, H. [=Halliwell].

1866 J. G. Nall  Great Yarmouth & Lowestoft 519 Bout-hammer, a blacksmith's heavy two-handed hammer.

The English Dialect Dictionary has bout-hammer sb. East Anglia ‘a blacksmith’s heavy two-handed hammer’ with an oral example from Norfolk.

This may be related in some way to OED’s about-sledge n., 1678–1990, as Halliwell-Phillipps (1846) suggests. If OED’s etymology for that word is correct, bout would have to be a shortening of about; but the earlier occurrence of bout hammer in the Essex Wills and elsewhere casts some doubt on this.

OED’s bout n.², sense 2 is: a ‘round’ at any kind of exercise, a turn or spell of work; as much of an action as is performed at one time’ (the antecedent to the familiar sporting sense). It is dated 1575, and could easily be earlier. This word is said by OED to be apparently a specialized sense of bought n.¹,  a bend, a curve, a loop of rope. It’s not clear whether the hammer sense could be directly connected with this word.

course of handles

1574 (III. 311) 12 course of handles

This is shearmen’s terminology. Shearmen’s equipment not infrequently includes handles. The ‘handles’ used seem to have been counted in ‘courses’. Compare: 

1985 S. Wright in L. Charles & L. Duffin Women & Work in Pre-industrial Eng. iii. 113 In 1610, for instance, George Davis left his apprentice a pair of shears and ‘four course of handles within one month after my wife shall leave of the trade which i dowe nowe use’.

This is probably OED’s course n. sense 29 ‘a set of things made or used at one time; spec. of candles made at once’. OED only exemplifies (from 1552, 1572, and 1712) courses of candles.

cronge and biche hook

There are (probably) two examples of cronge in the Essex Wills:

1569 (VIII. 216) a plough, chain, a ‘cronge’ [ploughing equipment]

1570 (II. 248) 1 ‘crouge’ otherwise called a ‘biche hooke’ [ploughing context]

It seems a reasonable assumption that crouge in 1570 is a mistranscription or scribal error for cronge, given that the latter is a word found elsewhere in the context of ploughing. 

cronge is discussed on page 301 of F. G. Emmison Elizabethan Life: Disorder (1970) but the meaning is said to be unclear. 

There is an OED entry cronge n. ‘A hilt or handle’ with one 1577 example from Harrison’s Description; here the cronge is the handle of a long spit; possibly the 1842 example below has a connection with this meaning. In our case we may assume that the word refers to something handle-like. 

Other examples:

1633 Q/SR 283/28 in Essex Rev. (1953) 62 215 Unam aliam ferri aratr anglice vocatam a crouge. [The editor explains this word as OED1’s crow sb. 1 ‘A piece of plough-iron’, but surely we have again the same error of u for n as in EW 1570.]

1800 W. Lucas Let. 12 June in Annals Agriculture 35 315, I find too, that by making the crongs (as they call them) of the whippletree moveable, the lever may be lengthened at either end so as to balance the strength of unequal-sized horses.

1841 W. Lucas Let. 17 July in Farmer’s Mag. 4 213 And a second swillyard, acting as a second lever, with the sling whippletree, or weightree, attached to it, with another foot chain and crong, would still further assist in keeping the beam horizontal, and the plough upright. [Lucas is from Broomfield, Essex: this is confirmed by a similar letter of 1839 in Farmer’s Mag. 3 (1839) 445 ‘to the editor of the Chelmsford Chronicle’.]

1842 in N. & Q. (1901) 346/2 Pitch bar and dung crong [Stebbing, Essex].

1904 N. & Q. 13, 77, 146.

1955 Essex Rev. 64 165 There are numerous entries of new ‘crongs’, when associated with a way-tree (always spelt ‘weytree’); it means the hook welded on to a band fastened to the middle of the way-tree. An entirely different use of the word ‘crong’ occurs in a single entry: ‘lining dung crong’; here it is equivalent to the word, still occasionally used, and recorded by Mr. Gepp under ‘crome’.

In Early English Books Online we find 1577, 1587 Holinshed ‘vp to the verye cronge’. This, and the 1842 example above, is probably the ‘handle’ sense. The term seems not to be in the English Dialect Dictionary. 

W. Lucas (1800 and 1841 above) is helpful in showing that the cronge is attached to the whippletree, which is the same thing as the swingletree (‘in a plough..a crossbar, pivoted at the middle, to which the traces are fastened, giving freedom of movement to the shoulders of the horse or other draught-animal). The 1955 example above confirms this, and tells us that the cronge is actually a hook welded to the swingletree (waytree is another synonym for this); not strictly a handle, but certainly a means of handling something. See the discussion of biche hook below.

Etymology: could this word be a derivative of the base of OE cringan, bearing the same relationship to it as crank does to crincan? OED at crank n.¹ says that crank is ‘apparently an ablaut-derivative of the verb crinc-an, cranc, crunc-en, found (but very rare) in Old English as a by-form of cring-an, crang, crung-en to fall in battle, of which the primitive meaning appears to have been ‘to draw oneself together in a bent form, to contract oneself stiffly, curl up’. Crong could be a parallel derivative of the commoner cringan; for the difference in vowel from crank compare song (sing) and bond (bind).

On the face of it, biche hook = ‘bitch hook’. This compound occurs in the same context as one of our cronge examples, if the emendation of crouge is correct:

1570 (II.  248) 1 ‘crouge’ otherwise called a ‘biche hooke’

The example itself states that it is a synonym of cronge. This matches the evidence compiled for that word which shows that a cronge is a hook welded to the swingletree of a plough as part of the apparatus by which the plough is attached to the draught animals.

In the Essex Wills we also find:

1577 (IV. 23) A dung rake, a long saw and a short, a mattock, a shod shovel, a spade, a grinding stone and the iron to turn it, a plough with coulter and share, a plough bitch, a double hook, an axe, a hedding [recte hedging] bill, a long and short pitchfork…

This again is a ploughing term and comes next to ‘a double hook’, which suggests that it may be the same thing.

Remarkably, there is a lumbering term bitch hook, attested, as far as I can see, only in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries, which is (see quot. 2007 below) ‘a grab hook on the doubletree of the horse’; the doubletree being ‘the cross-piece to which the swingle-tree of a carriage, plough, etc. is attached’ (OED), i.e. the exactly analogous part of the apparatus.

?1960 British Columbian Lumberman 44 10 The woods crew pre-set the chokers, which are immediately attached to the ‘bitchhook’ when the rigging is skinned back from the landing and spotted by the rigging-slinger.

1967 O. W. Blake Timber down the Hill 131 Bitch-Hook, extension hook to lengthen crotch line.

2007 D. MacKay Lumberjacks 95 The line was fastened to a ‘bitch hook’, a grab hook on the doubletree of the horse which then pulled the log quickly and easily up onto the growing pile once the cant-hook men had placed it in proper position by rolling it up a little ramp.

2008 Concise New Partridge Dict. Slang 59 bitch hook, an all-purpose quick-release hook for use with a tractor and chain CANADA, 1992

This would appear to be very much the same kind of thing; if it is, the term survived unrecorded for 400 years, surfacing in North America (the English Dialect Dictionary seems to have nothing on this).

The word doghook n. in the OED, which you might expect to have some connection with bitch hook, is of similar age (1528), though only in sense 1 ‘a hook used for leading a dog’; it does, however, have another sense (2a) ‘an iron bar with a bent prong, used to join parts of machinery, secure or hoist a log, etc.’, which dates only to 1821, but has overlap in sense with dog n.¹ 19a ‘a grappling iron with a spike for clutching an object to be hoisted (as a log or a barrel), or for driving into a log to secure it for sawing, transportation, etc.’ which dates back to 1538. It is not difficult to imagine that a bitch hook could be a variety of dog hook, rather as there are male and female screws, etc.

lathe or layer 

These are terms in the Essex Wills for what is almost certainly the same thing, an implement used in the making of cheese, paraphrased as a press in the quotation of 1543. The settlements from which the wills come are given in the lists below.

lathe:

Frating 1571 (III. 250) a cheese ‘leathe’ in the kitchen

Little Bentley 1584 (V. 173) 1 ‘lathe’ to make cheese

Langford 1588 (XI. 18) a lathe to make cheese

Tolleshunt Major 1592 (XI. 38) my cheese lathe and cheese press

South Hanningfield 1594 (XI. 169) cheese lath

Halstead 1596 (XII. 201) 1 moulding board, 1 lathe, 2 pair of quernstones

Fingringhoe 1597 (XII. 166) cheese lathe

Little Waltham 1597 (XII. 167) cheese lathe

Chelmsford 1599 (XII. 211) a grindstone, a lathe, an elmen plank in the sollar

Southminster 1580 (X. 119) the ‘lathe’, half the motes, an old cheese bread

South Hanningfield 1602 (XII. 129) cheese lathe

Examples outside Essex Wills (one apparently from Kent and two from Essex):

Church Commissioners: Rochester Capitular Estates CCRc_T137_01 (Medway Council City Archives) 30 September 1396. In the dairy a defective churn, a ring and a cheese lathe not appraised.

1543 Will of John Smyth 10 May in Trans. Essex Archaeol. Soc. (1865) 3 60 Item, a chese lathe or presse for chese. Item, thre chese breades.

1638 in F. W. Steer Farm & Cottage Inventories of Mid-Essex 1635–1749 (1969) 77 One cheese laethe, tow pootes, one braspoot.

layer (also lare):

Ramsey 1571 (IX. 128) cheese layer

Ingatestone 1574 (IX. 23) cheese-layer

St Osyth 1574 (IX. 60) cheese layer

Great Bromley 1577 (IV. 106) 2 saucers, a cheese ‘lare’, my great hutch

Ardleigh 1582 (IV. 158) 1 little table which should serve for a cheese, 1 ‘lare’

Ardleigh 1582 (IV. 158) 1 cheese ‘layre’

Havering 1588 (V. 97) a cheese layer with a great weight

Ramsden Bellhouse 1589 (V. 89) 1 cheese layer and the better half of my cheese motes

Example from outside the Essex Wills (still from Essex):

1574 Inventory of the goods and chattals of Henry Sydaye of Paglesham in Calendar of Queen’s Bench Indictments Ancient 639, Part II (Essex Record Office T/A 428/1/35) Item the chese lare and the troff to it and ij chese mottes iiijs.

No examples in the English Dialect Dictionary.

Here is a map showing the distribution of these words.

There may be no pattern here at all—or there may be some significance in the fact that the layer/lare forms are on the south-western and north-eastern edges and the lathe ones occupy a roughly oval central area.

These terms must be synonyms for ‘cheese ladder’, explained in the OED in the following quotation at ladder n. 3a:

1688 R. Holme Acad. Armory iii. 335/1 A Cheese Ladder..serveth to lay over the Cheese Tub for the Cheese Fat to rest upon, while the Dairy Woman presseth the Whay out of the Cruds. The cheese fat or vat is a wooden hoop with a loose bottom, both parts perforated with holes to let out the whey.

The English Dialect Dictionary explains cheese ladder as ‘a wooden framework to support a sieve through which milk is strained into colers or into the cheese-tub’; also at ladder sb. 2

Cheese ladder in early modern English is local to several counties, including Cheshire, Gloucestershire, Lancashire, Lincolnshire, Warwickshire, and Worcestershire; in the nineteenth century it is the general term for this implement.

Lathe is probably lathe n.³ sense 1 ‘a supporting structure, stand, or scaffold’, even though the evidence for this (quot. 1476 only) is so thin; the Danish word lad which shares its early Scandinavian etymon has the general sense ‘supporting structure’.  The cheese-making sense, then, may be just the last remaining trace of this.

As regards layer or lare, there is a very slightly better evidenced English word lare n.² (OED) meaning ‘turner’s lathe’ which is etymologized by OED as ‘? connected with LATHE n.³’. 

The English Dialect Dictionary has lare sb. ‘Obs. Dev. a turner’s lathe’; cites Horæ Subsecivæ (1777) 243 and Grose (1790) MS. Add. (M.); also Cotgrave Tournoir, a turners wheel, called a Lathe, or Lare.

So if lare could mean, or even be a variant form of, lathe in the wood-turning sense, and there also existed in Essex the synonymous terms cheese lathe and cheese layer/lare meaning ‘a support for the cheese (vat)’, it seems likely that these are forms of the same word, even though the phonological details are unclear. It is even perhaps possible that ladder, layer, and lathe are all alterations of an original form.

One further item in the Essex Wills that may be relevant is 

1586 (V. 317) turning laver

It is possible that ‘laver’ here represents a form of lathe. Turning lathe is a well-established term for what we now call simply ‘lathe’, though not attested in the OED as early as this. 

scruses

In the Essex Wills, apparently a double plural of screw.

1567 (VIII. 146) the pan bound the best, 2 ‘scruces’, best joined cupboard

1568 (VIII. 211) 2 pair of ‘skrouses’, 1 ‘genne’ and 1 ‘trysse’

1570 (II. 86) 2 pair of ‘scruses’ with all my ‘lystyng shores’ [perhaps read lyftyng shores] and the implements

1589 (V. 124), 1589 (XI. 173) 3 pair of ‘scruses’

Compare:

1588 (XI. 157) my 2 pairs of ‘skrewes’

OED records no occurrences of a double plural form of screw, and nor does it enter any sense of screw that might come in a pair; but compare these examples, where pairs of screws seem to be a large lifting device:

1791 Gentleman’s Mag. Oct. 889/2 Four pair of screws for raising ships that are stranded, in order to their being repaired.

1819 Blackwood’s Edinburgh Mag. June 357/1 The Admiralty yacht, lately under repair in Woolwich dock-yards, was, on the 12th instant, raised from her bearings sufficiently high to have the bottom of her keel coppered, by the application of a single pair of screws, under the direction of Mr W. Hookey, assistant builder. The vessel is one of 120 tons, having on board 30 tons of ballast, with all the stageing, &c. attached. The whole operation was performed by eight men, in five minutes; and Mr Hookey is decidedly of opinion, that he could, by the application of ten such pair of screws, which are those used in his bending machine, raise any frigate in the service.

In the Essex Wills 1570 example, the ‘scruses’ could be such a lifting device, if for ‘lystyng shores’ we were to read ‘lyftyng shores’; cf. the use of this term in:

1843 Architect, Engineer, & Surveyor  Jan. 43/2 The exterior angles of the tower at the north-east and south-east corners had given way. Two lifting shores of strong timber, 14 inches square, shod with iron at each end, were immediately inserted.

Shore here would be OED’s shore n.³ 1a ‘a piece of timber or iron set obliquely against the side of a building, of a ship in dock, etc., as a support when it is in danger of falling or when undergoing alteration or repair; a prop or strut.’ 

The following quotation, where scruses and shores are paired, seems to match the 1570 one above; if so, this is dealing with large-scale items for building repair:

1885 S. Tymms & J. R. Thompson Handbk. Bury St. Edmund’s (ed. 5) 91 The first Market Cross of which we have any record was erected by the Guildhall Feoffees in 1583-84, but was so badly built that twenty years after it was necessary to put ‘scruses and shores to uphold the same’.

The 1568 example may possibly contain words for two other mechanical devices, if genne is gin n. and trysse is trice n. (for the latter, see below).

But the 1567 example (the only one not in a pair) looks like a small domestic item. Are these examples relevant to it?

1605 Acct. in A. Constable Mem. George Heriot (1822) 202 Item, put to v great diamondis, v needles, and v scrues of gold, weighing xvj penyweight, inde ij li. viij s. Item, for making the said needles, and puting to the said scrues, ij li. x s.

1648 Will of Sir Edmund Bacon, Bart. in S. Tymms Wills & Inventories from Reg. Commissary Bury St. Edmunds (1850) 217, I give him alsoe my chaine of beads with scrues.

trysse 

1568 (VIII. 211) 2 pair of ‘skrouses’, 1 ‘genne’ and 1 ‘trysse’

Possibly a later example of trice n.¹, ‘a pulley or windlass’ (1357–1462); the three OED examples are from Ely, Promptorium (Norfolk), and Norwich. Given that skrouses may be a form of screw, and hypothesizing that genne is a form of gin n.¹ 3 ‘mechanical contrivance’, it would fit the context.  The English Dialect Dictionary has trise v. Lincs., Dorset, Somerset ‘to lift up, raise’.

wrybit

Essex Wills examples:

1583 (IV. 91) 2 wimbles, a wrybit, and a mattock

1584 (V. 24 2) axes, 1 wrybit and 1 broad chisel

This is clearly some sort of tool used by a carpenter: wry suggests something set at or incorporating an angle (cf. wry adj. 2a) and bit is normally the sharp end of a piercing tool (bit n.¹ 6: at present attested from 1594, later than this word). Note from the examples below that this term was carried across to New England, where it is quite commonly attested. Note also the variant spellings rye bit(t).

Earlier and later examples from outside Essex Wills (no evidence from Early English Books Online; the word is not listed by Holme in Acad. Armory):

[?a1547] in Letters and Papers, Foreign and Domestic, of the Reign of Henry VIII: Preserved in the Public Record Office, the British Museum, and Elsewhere, Volume 1, Part 2 1098 An ax, a wrybit and an awger.

[?date] in A Book of Strattons: Being a Collection of Stratton Records from England and Scotland, and a Genealogical History of the Early Colonial Strattons in America, with Five Generations of Their Descendants, Volume 1 (1908) 160 A cross cut saw, a handsaw, a hamer a perser stock, a wry bit, 3 axes, 2 wedges, a paire of beetle rings.

1652 Inventory of James Lindale of Duxburrow in Mayflower Descendant (1909) 11 90 It 2 chissels one wrybitt and an auger.

1671 Will & Inventory of John Barnes in E. A. Stratton Plymouth Colony (1986) 451 Item 3 Iron wedges 4 augers a wrybitt a handsaw an adds a bilhooke.

Possibly in: R. A. Salaman Dict. Tools used in Woodworking & Allied Trades (1975). 

1685 in C. M. Whipple A history of William Whipple of Dorchester, Massachusetts and Smithfield, Rhode Island, Whipple, 1652-1712 (2006) 24 Among his tools were a froe, a Rye bit, iron square, small jointer, carving tool, axe , clearing plane, whetting steel, wimble stock and bits, soding iron, compasses, and brass rule for a chalk line.

[?date] in Early Rec. Town of Providence (1894) 132 3 Chizells, i Gouge 00-01-04 2 Augers & a Rye bitt 00-02-00 2 bench hookes 2 hand sawes a drawing knife.

[?date] in E. B. B. Butler & M. M. M. Butler Planters Early New England (2009) 328 A croscutt saw, a hand saw, a hammer, a perser stock a wry bitt, 3 axes, 2 wedges.

It seems surprising that this everyday carpenter’s tool has escaped the notice of lexicographers.

The truth about eavesdropping; with a little light from Essex

Eavesdropping (noun and adjective) is illustrated in the OED (entry not yet revised) with examples from 1601 to ante 1861. An 1853 quotation aptly says: 

Eavesdropping consists in privily listening

a pretty good substitute for an explicit definition (which OED2 does not give).

This dual lexical item is attached to the entry for eavesdropper (noun). This word is given two definitions, which I will quote in reverse order. 

The first definition is the familiar:

One who listens secretly to conversation.

The second is a cross-reference to a quotation of 1641 which gives a legal definition:

Evesdroppers are such as stand under wals or windowes..to heare news. 

(The mention of ‘walls or windows’ is a clue to the origin of the term.) Eavesdropper goes back at least to 1487, when a certain Henry Rowley was adjudged by Nottingham juratores to be

communis evys-dropper et vagator in noctibus (a common eavesdropper and nightwalker)

There is of course a verb eavesdrop, but it is much later (1606) than eavesdropper; hence the latter is unlikely to be derived from it. Instead eavesdropper comes from a now obsolete noun, eavesdrop or (to modernize its Old English form) eavesdrip. This has nothing whatever to do with ‘privy listening’. As I said, ‘walls or windows’ gives a clue. It is the place where you stand to do your secret listening, or as the OED defines it:

the space of ground which is liable to receive the rain-water thrown off by the eaves of a building

literally:

the dripping of water from the eaves of a house.

The noun eavesdrop is very rarely recorded. The OED has an example from an Old English Kentish Charter and then no evidence till 1639 from the Wills and Inventories of Bury St Edmunds in a rather disguised form:

The..edifices..gardens, waies, water courses, easem^ts, ewse-dreepes, and appurtenances.

And after this two nineteenth century examples. The OED has a note in small type explaining the meaning further:

chiefly used with reference to the ancient custom or law which prohibited a proprietor from building at a less distance than two feet from the boundary of his land, lest he should injure his neighbour’s land by ‘eavesdrop’.

So while the completely transferred use of the verb, the agent noun, and the verbal noun are common and familiar, the original use is extremely rare (there are no examples on EEBO).

Into this gap of evidence comes an example of eavesdropping (noun) from the Essex Wills (1598 XII. 16): 

a chase way or passage to the premises, with sufficient ground for the eavesdropping

This is both the literal meaning ‘the space of ground which is liable to receive the rain-water thrown off by the eaves of a building’ and earlier by three years than the first example in the OED.

Yeting and yoting

Wills and inventories from many areas mention yeting vats and yoting vats, and the Essex Wills are no exception. There are at least five mentions of yoting vat: 

1560 (I. 280) from Harlow 

1569 (II. 238) from Great Dunmow 

1577 (IV. 10) (yauthing vat) from Great Waltham 

1581 (IV. 76) from High Laver 

1586 (XI. 244) from High Easter 

Also:

1563 (VIII. 123) yotting tub 

There are at least three mentions of yeting vat:

1559 (VIII. 15) (yetting vat) from Ugley, 1579 (IV. 204) from Toppesfield, also 1564 (I. 301), 1586 (X. 33) 

1587 (V. 259) (yeating vat) from Stebbing

The Editor of the Essex Wills has glossed several occurrences with an explanation that this was a vat for soaking barley, and there is no doubt that, despite the difference in the shape of yeting and yoting, they are the same word. 

The OED enters yoting, giving an example of the compound yowtyng faate from 1583, as a derivative under the verb yote, whose basic sense is ‘to pour’. Sense 2 is ‘to pour liquid upon; to soak’, clearly the sense of our compound: two of OED’s quotations mention ‘yoted wheat’ and brewer’s grains being ‘yoted’. The etymology states that it is a ‘local development’ (chiefly west and south-west) of Old English gēotan, explaining the latter by means of a cross-reference to the verb yet. 

Similarly OED has an entry for yeting which is referred back to the parent verb yet, also derived from Old English gēotan. 

Yote and yet are therefore dialectal doublets. The process which produced them must be the same that gave rise to such doublets as Chaucer’s forms to chese and to shete, beside modern English to choose and to shoot, and closely parallel to that which produced the doublets yelk and yolk. In more technical terms, the Old English diphthong ēo normally developed in Middle English into a long ē /e:/ which became modern English long e /i:/ or, if shortened, ĕ /ɛ/; but after a palatal consonant such as y /j/ or ch /tʃ/ the stress could shift to the second element and the first element then disappeared, giving Middle English long ō /o:/ and modern English oo /u:/ or Middle English long ǭ /ɔ:/, modern English /əʊ/, or if shortened ŏ /ɔ/.

OED, though it recognizes the ‘soak’ sense of yote and yoting and gives a single mention to yoting vat, makes no mention of the equivalent uses of yet and yeting at all; apart from the basic senses ‘pour, flow, gush’, etc., mostly with regard to water, the only extended senses have to do with molten metal. The Essex Wills together with several other collections of wills and inventories provide an important corrective to OED’s picture of the word. 

Moreover the Essex Wills show that yote was not chiefly a western and south-western variant. Both forms existed in 16th-century Essex within a few miles of each other. Our yet forms occur in a triangle to the north and north-east of the rough quadrilateral formed by our yote forms. This might be evidence of some kind of regional dialect boundary. 

There seems to be no evidence available from the chiefly literary texts on EEBO. Mainly south-western documentation is shown by the English Dialect Dictionary, which has yote v. from Glos. (also yeot), Wilts. (also yaught, yaut, yawt), Somerset (also yoat, yeot), and ‘West Country’; [jo:t, jɔ:t]. Sense 1 is ‘to pour; to water’; the example given is ‘the brewer’s grains must be well yoted for the pigs’ (Grose, 1790).

By contrast, non-literary documents, mainly wills and inventories, published in the last century or so, show multitudinous examples of yeting and (more commonly) yoting, from Berkshire, Cornwall, Devon, Hampshire, Oxfordshire, Surrey, Sussex, Somerset, and Wiltshire, as the following (which have not been directly consulted and therefore mostly lack exact documentary dates) demonstrate:

1587 in D. M. Herridge Surrey Probate Inventories, 1558–1603 (Surrey Record Society, Vo. 39) (2005) 237 The grynstone and all that bee long to it A yettynge trofe All the brasc. (also p. 438 yotinge fatte)

M. A. Havinden Household & Farm Inventories in Oxfordshire, 1550–1590 (1965) 50 A molding Bord and A poudering trowghe 1 0 0 A yotyng vate & three olde vates 4 0.

Sussex Notes & Queries (1944) Vol. 9 130 i ladefate, 2 stollages, i yotyng fate, i ost here, feble, for the ost there, i yelefate, i new ladder to the ost, i furneys. 

Surrey Record Society (2005) Vol. 39 298 one busshell, 8 tubbs, syxe kevers, one yotynge fate 13 4 

Berkshire probate accounts, 1583-1712 (1999) 33 one boltinge huche, three firkines, a yotinge fatte, one bushill. 

Devon & Cornwall Record Society (1997) Vol. 40 p. 40 Itm two yotinge vats & one olde hogshead. 

Hampshire Studies: Proceedings of the Hampshire Field Club and Archaeological Society (1996) Vol. 51 128 The malt howse a hogeshed, ii barelles, iii virkyns & a tubbe & a ester heare, iii wayshe vates 3. 4 ii shep skynes 8 iiii grat yotinge vates & ii litle yotinge vates.

1602 in Collectanea Archæologica (1871) 2 111One yotinge vate and frame . . xxs 

Devon & Cornwall Notes & Queries (1903) Vol. 2 135 A yotinge ffate. A chese wrynge.

Publications of the Bedfordshire Historical Record Society (1937) Vols. 19-20 71 In the mault house — two kyll haires, 12s; a yottinge fat, a boultinge hutche. 

L. Williams & S. Thomson Marlborough probate inventories, 1591-1775 (2007) 52
On yotting vate, on wishtub, on chespres, on renseve, on spad, on ruder 6s. 

Medieval Wills from Wells (Publications of the Somerset Record Society) (1925) 40 239 a great  ‘broche’, a ‘yowting’ tub, a kneeding ‘cowle’. 

F. G. Standfield Hist. East Meon (1984) 30 It. one yowtynge vate a keve a kever a cowle. 

Evidently yoting vats or tubs were everyday household items throughout southern England, and possibly further afield, in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. The fact that literary sources are silent about them just shows how much of the ordinary English language remained off the radar of ‘standard’ English.